Touch targets should be at least 44×44 CSS pixels with adequate spacing.
Add invisible padding to small icons; never rely on icon size alone for the hit area.
Design intuition says make targets comfortable; WCAG turns that into a checkable rule. Success Criterion 2.5.5 (AAA) asks for at least 44 by 44 CSS pixels, while the AA-level 2.5.8 sets a 24px floor with spacing exceptions. The value of a number is that it is auditable and, in many markets, tied to legal accessibility duties. “Looks tappable” is a matter of opinion; “44 by 44 CSS px with adequate spacing” either passes or it doesn't.
The criterion itself defines the exemptions: inline links inside a sentence, targets whose size is set by the browser, and cases with an equivalent alternative control are not held to the pixel floor. This is about conformance, not taste, so treat the exceptions as the standard writes them rather than inventing your own reasons to fall short.
An editing toolbar packs 24px icons 4px apart, with 'Delete' right beside 'Edit'. People keep destroying work they only meant to change.